What Expert Songwriters Do That Beginners Often Don’t

1. They Start With a Clear Concept

Experts don’t just write random lines—they know what the song is about from the start.

  • One emotion, one story, one point of view.

Beginner mistake: Trying to say too many unrelated things in one song.


2. They Use Specific, Vivid Imagery

Experts show, not just tell.

  • Instead of “I’m sad or mad,” they write in more detail.

Specifics evoke emotion better than generalities. 

The listener should be able to close their eyes and visualize what is going on.


3. They Obey—and Break—Structure Intentionally

Experts know the rules of song form: verse, chorus, bridge, etc.

  • When they break those rules, it’s on purpose for emotional or creative effect.

Beginners often lose listeners by writing songs with no clear structure or flow.


4. They Write Conversationally, Not Poetically

Many beginners try to sound “deep” or overly poetic.

  • Experts write how people speak, with rhythm and musicality.

Simple. Human. Honest.


5. They Edit Ruthlessly

Experts revise. A lot.

  • They replace lazy lines, tighten syllables, adjust rhyme schemes, and improve melodies.

Beginner mistake: Thinking the first draft is the final draft when its just the beginning.


6. They Focus on the Listener’s Experience

Experts write songs that make you feel something.

  • They consider: Will this line connect? Is this melody singable?
  • Their is a time and place for everything.

Beginners often focus only on their expression, not the listener’s journey.


7. They Use Contrast to Keep Interest

Experts balance highs and lows:

  • Soft verses vs. big choruses
  • Major chords vs. minor chords
  • Light lyrics vs. heavy lyrics

Beginner songs can feel flat if every section sounds or feels the same.


8. They Make Every Line Earn Its Place

Experts avoid filler.

  • If a line doesn’t serve the story, emotion, or rhythm—it gets cut or rewritten.
  • Short and to the point.


9. They Know How to “Zoom In” Emotionally

Instead of saying “I miss you or I love you”, they’ll describe a tiny, emotional moment that makes the listener feel it.

  • Think of songwriting as micro-storytelling: one moment, in sharp focus.
  • Capture a moment in time.


10. They Finish What They Start

  • Professionals finish songs—even bad ones—because each one teaches something.
  • Beginners often abandon songs halfway when they feel stuck and never improve.

 

Back to blog